AspDotNetStorefront vs Magento: The Payoff

By Jay Schneider

UPDATE (March 2016):  We just published an infographic comparing Magento Enterprise and AspDotNetStorefront version 10.  Check it out!

Editor’s note: This is the 5th and final installment of this series, addressing the business considerations of each platform. You can reference the ground-rules for the comparison here.

For any business looking for sizable growth from eCommerce, there’s really only one consideration when choosing an eCommerce platform: What revenue is produced for the investment made?

In this respect, for the first time, the platforms are very different.

Just a quick recap of where we’ve been, based on the Brilliance 3 pillars of eCommerce:

  • Attraction: SEO, responsive design for mobile and marketing through other shopping portals are all available for AspDotNetStorefront and Magento.
  • Conversion: Out of the box and other modules including reductive filtering, advanced search, one-page checkout, etc. help convert visitors to customers.
  • Maximization: Both tools offer to cross-sell, up-sell and related products, critical areas for maximizing the sale.
The Payoff
In terms of implementation, a business serious about eCommerce isn’t liable to see much difference in implementation costs.
 
According to this developer (see ‘Custom Magento Website’), the range for many businesses is in the range of $25-$60k for Magento.
 
For ease, let’s assume this is similar for custom stores on AspDotNetStorefront.
But the license—or subscriptions, as some vendors now call them—is a VERY different matter:
  • Magento Enterprise: $15,500 annually
  • AspDotNetStorefront: $1794 ($495 thereafter)
In other words, a business with a 25% margin would have to gross almost an additional $200k on a 3-year payoff…just to make up for the incremental license expenditure.

 
Summary
As mentioned from the first post, this is not an evaluation of AspDotNetStorefront or Magento from a technical standpoint.

But the real question has to do with how much money can be made. At the very least, AspDotNetStorefront Professional and Magento Enterprise are comparable platforms—with very UNCOMPARABLE licensing structures.

In the end, NOT choosing AspDotNetStorefront means you likely start out $200k behind.

Related Content

  • Weekly Educational Series

    Who Should Read This? Manufacturers and distributors looking for ideas how to grow their business leveraging digital commerce
    Need to Know: There are quick wins you can put in place without large investments

  • RFPs are Flawed

    Who Should Read This? Organizations using request for proposal (RFPs) documents
    Need to Know: Background questions are important. Doing your due diligence is important. Asking overly complicated questions to make yourself look smart, are not important. Ask yourself, what do we really need to know about this company in order to qualify them as a vendor. And if 100 questions are necessary, can you at least give that company the opportunity to present in person (or at minimum, web meeting)? Sure, that adds additional commitments to the decision makers but this project required a detailed RFP process; that same level of detail should be applied when reviewing the responses.

  • Insite Software and Episerver: How Episerver’s Acquisition of Insite Provides a Stronger Foundation for B2B Commerce Growth

    Who Should Read This? Episerver and Insite current and prospective customers.
    Need to Know: While it is less than 2 months into the combination, the product and engineering teams are aligned and excited about the near-term and future product roadmap, with clear synergies around best-in-class digital experience, personalization, commerce and analytics. Great news for Episerver and Insite current and prospective customers!

  • Year-end Showdown: Epi vs. Magento vs. Sitecore

    Who Should Read This? Decision-makers of B2B sellers looking for the best digital commerce platform.
    Need to Know: We have created a convenient free downloadable chart summarizing my last two articles Sitecore vs Episerver: Why Episerver is the Better Choice for Your B2B Business and Magento vs Episerver for B2B Digital Commerce: Revisited.

  • Magento vs Episerver for B2B Digital Commerce: Revisited

    Who Should Read This? B2B sellers considering Magento as their digital commerce platform.
    Need to Know: For you to grow against much larger online competitors, you need to select a software platform that enables you to demonstrate that you understand your customer, their pain points, and your products and services.

  • Sitecore vs Episerver: Why Episerver is the Better Choice for Your B2B Business

    Who Should Read This? Anyone currently using Sitecore or considering Sitecore for their B2B business.
    Need to Know: We reviewed Sitecore and Episerver several years back and made the choice to partner with Episerver because we believed Episerver’s ability to support efficient upgrades along with a strong commerce and content framework and innovative personalization tools was the best fit for our customers.